The Unsolved Murder of Keith Lyon Aged 12 (1967)

The Unsolved Murder of Keith Lyon

Keith Lyon was 12 years old when he was murdered on 6th May 1967. Keith was stabbed to death on his journey to buy something to add to his geometry set. He was murdered on a bridal pathway in Happy Valley, a large field on the outskirts of Brighton, between affluent Ovingdean and the village of Woodingdean.

Keith was the eldest son of band leader Kenneth Lyon and his wife Valda. Kenneth and Valda died without know who had murdered their son. Keith is survived by his brother, Peter, who was 7 years old at the time the murder.

No one has ever been brought to account for causing his brutal death.

The Murder of Keith Lyon

Keith Lyon

Keith was 12 years old when he was murdered. Keith attended Brighton and Hove Grammar School, and was wearing his school uniform at the time of his death.

Keith was stabbed 11 times in the back, chest and abdomen. The weapon was said to be a serrated kitchen knife.

Keith’s body was found by a 16 year old girl, out walking her dog at 4.15pm. Keith was lying by the bushes. She raised the alarm. It was noted that the pockets of Keith’s trousers had been pulled out and his four shillings and keys were missing.


‘Witnesses described a group of youths scuffling near where his body was found’.

‘Two women living nearby saw what they later described as four boys ‘sparring’ and apparently involved in a scuffle by some bushes on the path’

‘A bus driver reported seeing two youths in an ‘agitated’ state on his bus to nearby Whitehawk’

Investigation at the time

Keith Lyon 2

The news of an innocent child being stabbed to death ensured that a highly visible police investigation took place. Soon after the murder, the surrounding area was sealed off. The police set up an incident room within a local primary school, and officers from across Sussex were drafted in.

A large magnetic mine detector was brought over from Aldermaston; a heavy magnetic roller. This could pull metal objects from the ground. However, the alleged murder weapon, a blood stained knife, was discovered and handed in by some schoolboys, close to the rear of Fitzherbert School.

Evidence suggested that someone had tried to wash blood from their hands and clothes in a local public toilet block – a public lavatory that ‘only a local would have known of’.

The Brighton Dog Section was drafted to help seek the murderer, to no avail. The Police took great interest in local ‘beatniks, tramps and rough sleepers’.

A day after the murder a wax dummy was used in the area to help to jog the memories of potential witnesses. This didn’t elicit any further information.

A few days after Keith’s murder a rumour spread that Keith had been stabbed by a youth or gang of youths. The Police announced that they would fingerprint local boys. They hoped that boys evading the fingerprint process would help to highlight the murderers.

Coroner’s Report

In December 1967 the Police advised the Coroner that:

75,000 house visits had taken place
2000 written statements had been taken
17 schools had been visited
1900 school children were interviewed
6000 finger and palm prints had been taken
726 items of clothing were examined, 361 pieces were to be sent for forensic tests.

The blood on the steak knife that had been recovered by the schoolboys showed the blood type was the same as Keith’s.

The Jury returned a verdict of murder by person or persons unknown.

One year on

On the anniversary of Keith’s death in 1968 his father offered a £1000 award to anyone giving information that would lead to the arrest and conviction of the killer.

New Information in 1974

Detective Superintendent Jim Marshall announced in January 1974 that that new information about Keith’s Murder had come to light that ‘opens a new line of enquiry’. A special squad of detective began to re-interview dozens of people, though this renewed effort came to nothing.

Mislaid evidence

Keith Lyon 3

The alleged murder weapon and other items relating to Keith’s case were mislaid, seemingly after the reinvestigation in 1974. The knife was only found again by workmen in the basement of Brighton Police Station in 2002.


Rumours of inter-school rivalries abound. Keith went to a well-regarded ‘posh’ school, and his uniform could have marked him out as a target. Police are informed that a family abruptly emigrated to Canada, though they do not know who those people are, or whether there is a murder suspect within that family. ‘Apparently in the Keith Lyon case there was some suspicion directed at a gang of lads from Fitzherbert (school), in Woodingdean. No evidence of course’.

Notable Local Cases

Michael Trower went missing from Hove in 1966. His skeletal remains were discovered in 1967, on the outskirts of Brighton in a shallow grave. “The boy played truant a lot and failed to turn up at school when he went missing in 1966. His remains were found in January the following year. He had a large skull fracture but it was impossible to determine whether he had been sexually assaulted. That said, it was known Michael frequented amusement arcades and piers and he associated with known paedophiles.”

Michael’s murderer has never been found.

Vishal Mehrotra vanished in 1981. He was eight-years old. His remains were discovered in 1982 by pigeon shooters in remote marshland near Midhurst.

Vishal’s murderer has never been found.

Later suspects ‘to be questioned’

Three men have been arrested in connection with Keith Lyon’s murder. I can’t find a report of who these three people are.

Of interest is Brian Field (aka Brian Lull – born December 1937) – convicted of Roy Tuthill’s sexual assault and strangulation in Surrey in 1968. He may since have been questioned in connection with the deaths of Keith Lyon, Michael Trower and Vishal Mehrotra. Brian would have been 30 at the time of Keith Lyon’s murder – he worked for the Milk Marketing Board, so travelled often.

Unanswered Questions

Using up to date forensic technology – is the blood found on the alleged weapon actually Keith’s? At the time, the blood was found only to be of the same ‘type’. It is notable that only school aged boys were fingerprinted – if Keith’s murder took place today, would the investigation take into account other suspect types? What was the new information that led to a new investigation using a ‘new line of enquiry’ in 1974?

Keith Lyon – My full research, maps, timeline and sources

  1. Keith Lyon’s body found (1967)
  2. Michael Trower’s remains found (1967) (went missing in 1966)
  3. Roy Tuthill’s remains found (1968)
  4. Vishal Mehrotra’s remains found (1982) (went missing in 1982)

6 responses

    • Absolutely. I highly doubt that this was a crime by children…a teacher would be a good lead. I’m sure the murderer was a man – I’m intrigued by the mention of ‘washed off blood’ found in public toilets that ‘only locals would know of.’ I’ve lived in the area for over 10 years and know of no public toilets.

      • That is interesting. Most of these abductions, murders, have a public toilet involved, as it seems to attract paedophiles looking for boys. The fact this was a grammar school is also interesting, and the fact that he was wearing his school uniform at the time.
        All these facts sound very like the abduction of Martin Allen in 1979. Do you have any newspaper reports of this, like local newspapers etc. Where do you think the toilet was? If there was a knife then DNA from it now could be taken, as it must be in the file of evidence.
        Was where he was found, a long distance from his home?

      • Thank you so much for taking an interest in this. I really feel compelled to try and help to raise the profile of this case – the excellent LBC coverage of Vishal’s case has strengthened my resolve. I only have online newspaper archives to go on, but I’m sure the library will have newspaper reports that I can look at. I should. With regard the the public toilet, I have no idea where that was. I don’t believe there are any in the area at the moment.

        The DNA is an interesting one, as the weapon was ‘mislaid’ by Sussex police for decades, only re-discovered in 2002 by workmen. It was in the basement of Brighton Police Station. That is pretty shocking in itself – how could such a high profile murder’s weapon get lost? It was after the Police had re-opened their inquiries in1974…perhaps someone didn’t like what those enquiries raised?

        I believe that his body was found close to home, but again, I’d have to check the library archives for a clue about where exactly he lived.

        Thank you for asking these questions.

        I just found this ITN report from the time:

  1. Very well-written post! Regrettably some murders will never be solved. Apart from Keith Lyon’s case, there is 25-year-old Suzie Lamplugh, the West London estate agent who went missing in 1986. Keep writing!

    • Thank you chum. I just hate that these things get forgotten – that we can all just carry on as normal when such atrocities take place. Suzy Lamplugh’s family have an excellent charity that now aims to help lone workers to stay safe. Hopefully that will help to stop the same fate falling to others. I always think of Claudia Lawrence, too. I hate how her poor family must be feeling.

      Anyway, thank you for stopping by – and stay safe out there! We all should look out for each other 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s